Skip to main content

It’s not DNS: Ensuring high availability in a hybrid cloud environment

 


Our customers have multi-faceted requirements around DNS forwarding, especially if they have multiple VPCs that connect to multiple on-prem locations. As we discussed in an earlier blog post, we recommend that customers utilize a hub-and-spoke model, which helps get around reverse routing challenges due to the usage of the Google DNS proxy range.

But in some configurations, this approach can introduce a single point of failure (SPOF) within the hub network, and if there are connectivity issues within your deployment, it could cause an outage in all your VPC networks. In this post, we’ll discuss some redundancy mechanisms you can employ to ensure that Cloud DNS is always available to handle your DNS requests.


A non-redundant hub and spoke DNS architecture.jpg

Figure 1.1 - A non-redundant hub and spoke DNS architecture

Adding redundancy to the hub-and-spoke model

If you need a redundant hub-and-spoke model, consider a model where the DNS-forwarding VPC network spans multiple Google Cloud regions, and where each region has a separate path (via interconnect or other means) to the on-prem network. In the image below, VPC Network H spans us-west1 and us-east1 and each region has a dedicated Interconnect to the customer’s on-prem network. The other VPC networks are then peered with the hub network.

A highly available hub-and-spoke architecture.jpg

Figure 1.2 - A highly available hub-and-spoke architecture

This scenario provides highly available DNS capabilities, allowing the VPC to egress queries out of either interconnect path, and allowing return queries to return via either interconnect path. The outbound request path always leaves Google Cloud via the nearest interconnect location to where the request originated (unless a failure occurred, at which point it uses the other interconnect path). 

Note, while Cloud DNS will always route the request back to on-prem through the interconnect closest to the region, the responses back from the on-prem network to Google Cloud will depend on your WAN routing. In cases with equal cost routing in place, you may see asymmetric routing behaviors on the return responses, which take a different path than the way they went, and may introduce additional resolution latencies in some cases. 

Alternative DNS setups

A highly available hub-and-spoke model isn’t an option for all companies, though. 

Some organizations’ IP address space consists of a mixture of address blocks across many locations. This often happens to companies as a result of a merger or acquisition, which can make it difficult to set up a clean geo-based DNS. Let’s look at a different DNS setup and how customers may have to adapt for failures of the DNS stack.

To understand the problem, consider the case of a Google Cloud customer that was managing U.S. East Coast DNS resolvers for East Coast-based VPCs, and U.S. West Coast resolvers for West Coast-based VPCs, in order to reduce latency for DNS queries. The challenge arose when it came time to build out redundancy. Specifically the customer wanted a third set of resolvers to provide backup for both east and west coast resolvers in the event of a failure of either of the resolvers.  

Unfortunately, a setup like Figure 1.3 could cause issues in a failure scenario.

Multiple Hub and Spokes.jpg

Figure 1.3 - Multiple Hub and Spokes With a Single Set Of Backup DNS Resolvers

In this setup, the failure of the West Coast DNS resolvers would result in traffic being forwarded to the backup servers running in the central US, with the source IP addresses for these DNS requests corresponding to Google Cloud’s DNS proxy server address range (35.199.192.0/19). But because there are two VPCs and the WAN sees two different routes to get back to the Google Cloud DNS proxy server address range, it would typically route the return requests back via the closest link advertising the Google Cloud DNS proxy IP range. In this case, that would be the east coast interconnect. And because the east coast interconnect connected to a different VPC than originated the request, the response would be dropped by the Google Cloud DNS proxies (since the Virtual Network ID (VNID) of the return packets would be different from the VNID for the east coast VPC). The problem herein lies with the routing and subnet advertisements, not the DNS layer itself.  

So the question becomes, how do you support network topologies with multiple VPCs and DNS resolvers while still providing HA DNS resolvers on-premise?

One approach is to proxy the DNS request as shown in Figure 1.4 below. By forwarding all DNS requests to a proxy setup within the VPC (or even within a specific subnet, depending on your desired granularity), you end up with VPC-specific IP addresses making it easy for the on-prem infrastructure to correctly send their responses back to the correct VPC. This also simplifies on-prem firewall configurations because you no longer need to open them up for Google’s DNS proxy IP range. Since you can specify multiple IP addresses for DNS forwarding, you can run multiple proxy VMs for additional proxy redundancy and further bolster your availability.

Insertion of Proxy VM For HA DNS Configuration.jpg

Figure 1.4 - Insertion of Proxy VM For HA DNS Configuration

Highly available DNS: the devil is in the details

DNS is a critical capability for any enterprise, but setting up highly available DNS architectures can be complex. It’s easy to build a highly redundant DNS stack that can handle many failure scenarios, but overlook the underlying routing until something fails and DNS queries are unable to resolve. When designing a DNS architecture for a hybrid environment, be sure to take a deep look at your underlying infrastructure, and think through how failure scenarios will impact DNS query resolution. 











Comments

What's Popular ?

Use Vault for Gmail Confidential Messages and Jamboard Files

Google vault will be supporting two new formats in the future, Gmail confidential mode emails & Jamboard files stored in Google Drive. Google Vault gives you a chance to retain, hold, search, and export data to support your organization’s retention and eDiscovery needs. This dispatch includes support for new information types with the goal that you can thoroughly oversee your association's information. What happens when individuals in your association sends confidential messages? Vault can hold, retain, search, and export all confidential mode messages sent by users in your association. Messages are constantly accessible to Vault, notwithstanding when the sender sets a termination date or denies access to private messages. Here’s an example of what admin@ink-42.com will see in Vault when they search for sam@ink-42.com and preview this email sent by lisa@ink-42.com . But It’ll not work vise versa. Admins can hold, retain, search and export message headers and s

All you need to know about Cloud Storage

Cloud Storage is a global, secure, and scalable object store for immutable data such as images, text, videos, and other file formats. You can add data to it or retrieve data from it as often as your application needs. The objects stored have an ID, metadata, attributes, and the actual data. The metadata can include all sorts of things,  including the security classification of the file, the applications that can access it, and similar information. The ID, metadata, and attributes make object storage an appealing storage choice for a large variety of applications ranging from web serving to data analytics.    Storage classes You store objects in buckets that are associated with a project, which are, in turn, grouped under an organization. There are four storage classes that are based on budget, availability, and access frequency.  Standard buckets for high-performance, frequent access, and highest availability - Regional or dual-regional locations for data accessed frequently or high-th

Zoom’s Work Transformation Summit on Jan. 19: Fresh Approaches for Moving Forward

These past two years have undoubtedly reshaped work. More specifically, these past two years — shuffling between remote, in-person, and hybrid work scenarios — reshaped what employees expect out of their jobs, how they want to work, and what the office means to them.  Organizations are challenged with making big decisions to meet those expectations, and those decisions will dramatically alter how they hire, manage their facilities, buy technology, and maintain productivity. Simply adjusting policies and retooling previous work models won’t do. It takes a comprehensive reimagining. To help organizations navigate this next phase of work, Zoom is hosting our  Work Transformation Summit  on Jan. 19, a free, half-day virtual event designed to provide you and your organization with meaningful strategies, creative approaches, and innovative solutions for redefining work.  Summit attendees will have the opportunity to hear from peers and industry experts on the importance of embracing technolo

What’s new with Google Cloud

  Want to know the latest from Google Cloud? Find it here in one handy location. Check back regularly for our newest updates, announcements, resources, events, learning opportunities, and more.  Week of Mar 8-Mar 12 2021 Learn about the value of no-code hackathons —Google Cloud’s no-code application development platform, AppSheet, helps to facilitate hackathons for “non-technical” employees with no coding necessary to compete. Learn about Globe Telecom’s no-code hackathon as well as their winning AppSheet app  here . Introducing Cloud Code Secret Manager Integration — Secret Manager  provides a central place and single source of truth to manage, access, and audit secrets across Google Cloud. Integrating  Cloud Code  with Secret Manager brings the powerful capabilities of both these tools together so you can create and manage your secrets right from within your preferred IDE, whether that be VS Code, IntelliJ, or Cloud Shell Editor.  Learn more . Flexible instance configurations in Clou

New intelligent suggestions for formulas and functions in Google Sheets

  You’ll now see in-line, sequential, context-aware suggestions for formulas and functions when working with data in Google Sheets.  Formula suggestions will make it easier to write new formulas accurately and help make data analysis quicker and easier. Simply begin inserting a formula in Sheets—suggestions will be automatically displayed and as you continue to type. You can view additional incremental suggestions in the drop-down menu. We hope these formula suggestions make it easier and faster for you to work with and analyze your data. Admins: There is no admin control for this feature. End users: This feature will be available  by default and can be disabled by going to Tools > Enable formula suggestions or from the three-dot menu of the suggestion dialog box. Rapid Release and Scheduled Release domains: Gradual roll-out (up to 15 days for feature visibility) starting on August 25, 2021 Available to all Google Workspace customers, as well as G Suite Basic and Business customers

Your support partner for Google Workspace / Microsoft 365

Your Support Partner For Google Workspace / Microsoft 365     Remote work is here to stay. Forbes.com mentions the percentage of "remote-capable" professionals who expect to work part of their time in the office and part of their time elsewhere—even if it's just one day a week—has risen to 53%, with even more, 59%, indicating that this is their preference. Today, 42% of respondents indicate they work in a hybrid arrangement, and 53% believe they will continue to do so in the future. With this emerging yet consistent trend, it should always be backed up with responsive & effective system support for your Google Workspace - which also provides you with the top notch collaboration tools to connect, create & collaborate.  1. Support at your ease.  Our Google Workspace Service offering thrives to enable you the full potential to work from anywhere, anytime. We stand by you for any Google Wor
Every sustainable business realizes that cloud migration is essential for long-term success. However, many people are hesitant to begin the migration process because they fear data loss and are hesitant to take such an enormous leap. Nevertheless, the reality is that  data will continue to grow, necessitating additional infrastructure to handle it, both in terms of data storage and processing power for effective use of data. Organizations that are hesitant to transition to the cloud sometimes miss out on the benefits that cloud-native capabilities can deliver, such as faster machine learning timelines and the potential to leverage artificial intelligence to harvest more insights from data. If at all your organization is hesitant to move to the cloud, we got you covered! Finetech offers end to end service in all aspects of Data Migration. This would not only from on-premises to the cloud, but also : Cloud (3rd party Cloud Email providers) to Google Cloud PST (local archives) to Google C
Big announcement!  As a part of our growth, Finetech is pleased to announce the expansion of our business in Bangladesh. With 12 years of excellence in helping organizations to digitize and providing with all aspects to keep up with the relevant, and up-to-date technology required to create an efficient workplace, Finetech Pledges to do so for the years to come throughout South Asia. As an objective to bring about the best Cloud services to South Asia, we have now kick-off our venture in Bangladesh.  We have identified Bangladesh as a fast developing country, and the need for an efficient work environment has been in need ever since. We understand the urgent technology challenges organizations face with incessantly changing tortuous business requirements. We also understand that orthodox ways of seeking solutions for these problems are no longer valid in the present day. We at Finetech believe that Cloud is the next big wave in technology. Our purpose is to bring the best of Cloud solu

Set start times and import reminders in Tasks

Here comes one of the most awaited features. Tasks is one of the goals to follow what you have to do in G Suite. These new updates will help ensure the majority of your to-dos are in Tasks, and guarantee that you can monitor the due dates related with them. Moreover, importing reminders to Tasks can support your users if your association is at present changing from Inbox to Gmail. Set a date and time for your tasks and receive notifications - You’ll find a place to add date & time. Create repeating tasks - Also you can make an event recur. Import reminders into Tasks This import tool will pull your reminders (from Inbox/Gmail, Calendar, or the Assistant) into Tasks.When importing reminders into Tasks, we’ll copy over the title, date, time and recurrence of the reminder. Please note, reminders with locations associated will not be imported. Additionally, this is a one-time import and not a constant sync. - When you open Tasks on the web or your mobile app, you’ll se

Live translated captions in Google Meet are now generally available

What’s changing  In 2021, we announced a beta for live translated captions in Google Meet. We’re now making live translated captions generally available for select Google Workspace editions.  Meeting participants can translate English meetings to:  French  German  Portuguese  Spanish  Translated captions are available on Google Meet on web and mobile devices.  Who’s impacted  End users  Why it’s important  Translated captions help make Google Meet video calls more inclusive and collaborative by removing language proficiency barriers. When meeting participants consume content in their preferred language, this helps equalize information sharing, learning, and collaboration and ensures your meetings are as effective as possible for everyone. This feature can be particularly helpful for all-hands meetings or training meetings with globally distributed teams. Additionally, translated captions can be impactful in education settings, allowing educators to connect and interact with students, p